The Anna Wintour Playbook: How Not to Execute Leadership Succession
Why Vogue's "transition" reveals the leadership crisis plaguing organizations everywhere
Anna Wintour made headlines in late June 2025 by announcing her departure as Editor-in-Chief of American Vogue after 37 years. But if you read past the initial headlines, you'll discover something troubling: she's not actually leaving.
Wintour will remain Condé Nast's Chief Content Officer and Vogue's Global Editorial Director, continuing to oversee the very empire she built. In other words, she's stepping down while stepping nowhere.
This isn't just a fashion media story. It's a cautionary tale about succession planning gone wrong—and it's happening in organizations everywhere.
The Shadow Leadership Epidemic
From nonprofit executives who become "emeritus" board members to tech founders who remain as "advisors," we're witnessing a generation of leaders who've mastered the art of appearing to leave while maintaining control. The result? Organizations trapped in leadership limbo, with successor leaders operating in permanent shadows.
The symptoms are everywhere:
Decisions that mysteriously get "reviewed" by former leaders
New executives who defer to predecessors on major choices
Board meetings where the "advisor" dominates discussions
Innovation that stalls because "that's not how we've always done it"
Why Leaders Won't Leave
The psychology behind failed transitions runs deeper than ego. Many long-tenured leaders genuinely believe their organizations can't survive without them. They've become so intertwined with institutional identity that separation feels like organizational death.
But here's the truth: When you design a transition that keeps the predecessor hovering over every major decision, you're not protecting the organization—you're strangling it.
The Real Cost of Succession Theater
Stunted Growth: Organizations led by shadow figures can't evolve. Innovation requires authentic authority, not permission from the previous regime.
Confused Accountability: When ultimate decision-making authority remains unclear, responsibility becomes diffused. Problems fester because no one knows who's really in charge.
Successor Development Crisis: You can't develop real leadership in someone else's shadow. Future leaders need space to fail, learn, and establish their own credibility.
Stakeholder Confusion: Donors, partners, and team members need clarity about who's driving the ship. Mixed messages erode confidence and commitment.
What Authentic Succession Looks Like
Real leadership transitions require three non-negotiables:
Clear Authority Transfer: The new leader must have genuine decision-making power, not just a fancy title. If major choices still flow through the predecessor, you haven't transferred leadership—you've created middle management.
Defined Exit Timelines: Authentic transitions include hard deadlines for the predecessor's involvement. "Advisory" roles should have expiration dates, not indefinite extensions.
Board Accountability: Governance bodies must enforce clean transitions, even when it's uncomfortable. Allowing founders or long-term leaders to dictate succession terms is board failure, not loyalty.
The Wintour Warning
What makes Wintour's situation particularly instructive is how it reveals institutional enabling. Condé Nast's board essentially told their next Editor-in-Chief that they don't trust them to actually lead. That looks like hunger for power dressed up as strategic planning and succession.
The expensive myth driving most succession failures is the belief that some leaders are truly irreplaceable. But sustainable organizations are built on systems, values, and processes—not individual personalities.
Moving Forward
If you're a leader planning your own transition, ask yourself: Are you preparing to leave, or just rearranging your titles?
If you're on a board overseeing succession, demand clarity: What does "stepping down" actually mean? Who has final authority? When does the predecessor's involvement end?
The organizations that thrive are those that master the art of authentic leadership transfer. They understand that true legacy isn't about maintaining control—it's about building something strong enough to survive and flourish without you.
Anna Wintour may have redefined fashion, but her approach to succession planning offers a masterclass in what not to do. The question is: Will your organization learn from her mistakes, or repeat them?
If you’re a YouTube user, please head over to the video on this topic here, and share with your network!
Need help navigating leadership succession in your organization? Reach out to us to explore creating transitions that actually work.